Vancouver’s empty homes tax should stay at 1% to ensure it’s still being paid: staff

Vancouver's empty homes tax should not be increased beyond its current rate in order to ensure people keep paying it, a city staff report states.

While the report, which will be presented to city council on Tuesday, said further exemptions for second homes should not go ahead, staff do recommend further exemptions to homes under renovation.

The tax applies a one per cent levy on a home's assessed value if owners cannot prove they occupy the property for more than six months of the year, either themselves or with renters.

The report comes after a review of the tax was ordered by council earlier this year to study the policy's effects on the housing market and its overall fairness.

Questions about raising the tax rate popped up during the most recent municipal election, with then-candidate Kennedy Stewart vowing to raise it up to three per cent. Stewart continued to pursue the idea after winning the election.

But staff say raising the tax rate would risk non-compliance, particularly among homeowners who are also subject to the province's speculation tax.

"Housing policy and tax experts engaged by staff during the review expressed strong concern about the potential for an increase in the tax rate to incentivize non compliance and avoidance," the report states.

Instead, those experts called for stricter penalties for not paying the tax, which staff said they intend to review with the province.

Some exemptions exist for the tax, including properties under renovation, property transfer, and strata rental restrictions.

While staff rejected a proposed exemption for second homes that are used part time through the year, the report does suggest further exemptions for renovated properties.

The proposed amendment would add together the tenancy time and the amount of time spent qualifying for permits to renovate or redevelop properties, after the city heard complaints from owners about being charged the tax while waiting for permits to be approved by the city.

READ MORE: Vancouver collects $21M from empty homes tax, expects $38M total for first year 

That sticking point formed the basis of one of several lawsuits launched this year against the city over the tax.

Overall, staff say the tax has been effective in its goal of adding more homes to the rental market and generating revenue for the city to put towards affordable housing projects.

The latest data shows the city collected $39.4 million in revenue during the 2018 tax year from the owners of 1,989 vacant properties.

READ MORE: City of Vancouver facing multiple lawsuits over empty homes tax 

That's more money from less properties than in 2017, when 2,538 homes generated $38 million in revenue.

An extra $22.1 million was collected from non-compliance audits on 892 properties.

In addition to the drop in vacant properties, the city found the number of properties tenanted went up by seven per cent from 2017 to 2018, from 46,770 to 50,102.

"At this point, based on consultation with tax experts, housing experts, the public, and other stakeholders, the tax is working mostly as intended and minimal further amendments are recommended at this time," the report states.

"The data also supports this conclusion with key indicators showing trends that point to the tax working to encourage occupancy."

Provided by: Sean Boynton for Global News

Photo: © Darryl Dyck/CP 

Simon Fraser
Market Update

Simon Fraser Condos

Altaire by Polygon

Altaire built in 2008/2009 reaches higher then any other condo building in Metro Vancouver offering panoramic views.

Novo I by Intergulf

Novo I built in 2007 known for the amazing sight lines and views from most units and balconies up to 1000 sq ft.

Novo II by Intergulf

Novo II built in 2007 known for the amazing sight lines and views from most units and balconies up to 1000 sq ft.

Aurora by Polygon

Aurora built in 2006 with 103 condos featuring 36 unique floor plans ranging from 715 sq ft to 1500 sq ft.

One University by Millennium

One University built in 2005 is UniverCity's flagship building with luxury homes featuring semi private elevators.

Harmony by Polygon

Harmony built in 2005 was the first condo development at Univercity & as a result offers a unique setting & views.

Serenity Townhomes by Polygon

Serenity is a collection of 2 bedroom townhomes of 1100 sq ft ranging to 4 bedroom 2000+ sq ft townhomes.

The Hub by Liberty Homes

The Hub built in 2009 is set atop Nester's Grocery and steps from High Street giving these homes an urban feel.

Verdant by VanCity Enterprises

Verdant is a two storey town home building built with environmental design and stylish living spaces which complement the modern exterior of these SFU homes.

Origin by Porte Development

Origin is designed by GBL Architect & BYU Interior Designs, developed by Porte Development Corp. and marketed by Red Dot Real Estate.

Nest by Mosaic

Located on UniverCity High Street across from the new University Highlands elementary schools this refreshing building will add further depth to a growing community.

Highland House by Liberty Homes

A 12-storey concrete high-rise development and targeted towards Rental Investors and First-Time Condo Buyers.

Lift by Porte Development

Lift will be a wood frame building comprising of 56 homes. Building technologies, environmental features, and price points should be similar to Origin.

Altitude by Hungerford Group

Altitude will be a 2 tower development comprising of a 12 and 14 story building with a total of 210 strata units.

CentreBlock by Liberty Homes

CentreBlock at UniverCity atop Burnaby Mountain is the latest condo project with sales commencing early 2014. .

Reciprocity Logo The data relating to real estate on this website comes in part from the MLS® Reciprocity program of either the Greater Vancouver REALTORS® (GVR), the Fraser Valley Real Estate Board (FVREB) or the Chilliwack and District Real Estate Board (CADREB). Real estate listings held by participating real estate firms are marked with the MLS® logo and detailed information about the listing includes the name of the listing agent. This representation is based in whole or part on data generated by either the GVR, the FVREB or the CADREB which assumes no responsibility for its accuracy. The materials contained on this page may not be reproduced without the express written consent of either the GVR, the FVREB or the CADREB.