No more housing rule changes, mortgage group urges federal government

The group that represents mortgage brokers across Canada was in Ottawa on Tuesday to urge parliamentarians to tinker with their recent rule changes, and hit the brakes on any new ones.

Mortgage Professionals Canada, who represents more than 11,000 mortgage brokers, urged lawmakers to rethink rule changes introduced last October aimed at reining in consumers who may be taking on too much debt to buy a home. Among the major changes was the implementation of a "stress test" whereby borrowers would be judged on their ability to pay their mortgage assuming that rates were much higher than they are right now.

The yardstick for that test is what's known as the Bank of Canada's qualifying rate — the average of the posted rates at Canada's Big 5 banks — which is currently 4.64 per cent.

While it's easy to get a mortgage rate below three per cent at the moment, the new "stress test" means that borrowers have their finances gauged against a much higher bar, in case real rates inch up. The aim was to clamp down on speculation and high debt, but the result has been to reduce purchasing power for new borrowers, MPC says.

A homeowner making $80,000 a year would likely qualify for a 2.5 per cent mortgage and allow them to buy a $400,000 home, CEO Paul Taylor said. But with the higher stress test level, they'd only qualify for a home worth about $320,000 — a reduction of about 20 per cent, he said. 

Other changes to limit portfolio reinsurance have disproportionately hurt smaller lenders, which helps the big banks. And setting the stress test level based on posted rates at big banks allows them to set their own competitive advantage, Taylor said at a parliamentary committee last month.

"These are costs that will be passed on to consumers," he said.

Instead of setting the stress test based on a level the big banks can skew to their advantage, "set the stress test based on a market rate," MPC said, or have the Bank of Canada set a rate that is independent of the average of the banks posted rates.

Worse still, Taylor said Tuesday, is that the new rules have done nothing to cool the housing markets in hot places like Toronto and Vancouver, while harming the market elsewhere. "By virtue of making it harder to get on the property ladder, there's an oversupply in some markets," Taylor said.

Meanwhile, "Toronto and Vancouver have supply issues," he said, "so they're almost isolated because people will pay whatever is required to get into the market."

Other markets are being hurt by tougher rules, and that's playing out in sales and prices. While the winter months are typically a time of seasonal slowdown for home sales, MPC says new mortgage originations are down by about 20 per cent since the new rules kicked in.

"So let's slow down and hit pause," MPC chair Mark Kerzner said.

He said the group isn't necessarily asking Ottawa to overturn the new rules, but at least consider tinkering with them and certainly avoid bringing in any new ones.

"Take 12 to 18 months to assess the impact of changes already made," Kerzner said.

Budget time

The push comes as Ottawa is set to unveil an annual budget that may well contain new measures to rein in house prices. While the most recent figures suggest prices are indeed flattening nationally, they were still up by 15 per cent in Vancouver and by 22 per cent in Toronto in the year up to January.

While Ottawa considers what to include in the budget, the mortgage group is urging them to not take any drastic and unnecessary action because of isolated pockets of danger.

The new rules "disproportionately affect competitive positions of small and mid-sized lenders," Kerzner said. "There's a real and growing sentiment that activity in Toronto and Vancouver is negatively impacting those in the rest of the country."

 From the CBC on MSN Money

Simon Fraser
Market Update

Simon Fraser Condos

Altaire by Polygon

Altaire built in 2008/2009 reaches higher then any other condo building in Metro Vancouver offering panoramic views.

Novo I by Intergulf

Novo I built in 2007 known for the amazing sight lines and views from most units and balconies up to 1000 sq ft.

Novo II by Intergulf

Novo II built in 2007 known for the amazing sight lines and views from most units and balconies up to 1000 sq ft.

Aurora by Polygon

Aurora built in 2006 with 103 condos featuring 36 unique floor plans ranging from 715 sq ft to 1500 sq ft.

One University by Millennium

One University built in 2005 is UniverCity's flagship building with luxury homes featuring semi private elevators.

Harmony by Polygon

Harmony built in 2005 was the first condo development at Univercity & as a result offers a unique setting & views.

Serenity Townhomes by Polygon

Serenity is a collection of 2 bedroom townhomes of 1100 sq ft ranging to 4 bedroom 2000+ sq ft townhomes.

The Hub by Liberty Homes

The Hub built in 2009 is set atop Nester's Grocery and steps from High Street giving these homes an urban feel.

Verdant by VanCity Enterprises

Verdant is a two storey town home building built with environmental design and stylish living spaces which complement the modern exterior of these SFU homes.

Origin by Porte Development

Origin is designed by GBL Architect & BYU Interior Designs, developed by Porte Development Corp. and marketed by Red Dot Real Estate.

Nest by Mosaic

Located on UniverCity High Street across from the new University Highlands elementary schools this refreshing building will add further depth to a growing community.

Highland House by Liberty Homes

A 12-storey concrete high-rise development and targeted towards Rental Investors and First-Time Condo Buyers.

Lift by Porte Development

Lift will be a wood frame building comprising of 56 homes. Building technologies, environmental features, and price points should be similar to Origin.

Altitude by Hungerford Group

Altitude will be a 2 tower development comprising of a 12 and 14 story building with a total of 210 strata units.

CentreBlock by Liberty Homes

CentreBlock at UniverCity atop Burnaby Mountain is the latest condo project with sales commencing early 2014. .

Reciprocity Logo The data relating to real estate on this website comes in part from the MLS® Reciprocity program of either the Greater Vancouver REALTORS® (GVR), the Fraser Valley Real Estate Board (FVREB) or the Chilliwack and District Real Estate Board (CADREB). Real estate listings held by participating real estate firms are marked with the MLS® logo and detailed information about the listing includes the name of the listing agent. This representation is based in whole or part on data generated by either the GVR, the FVREB or the CADREB which assumes no responsibility for its accuracy. The materials contained on this page may not be reproduced without the express written consent of either the GVR, the FVREB or the CADREB.